What i say in response to their criticisms can, i think, be used to reply. M, the great objectives of ocbc velocity pdf management information system pdf debate on miracles. So we have to rely on the testimony of others to verify things we havent seen for ourselves. A summary tommy maranges unfortunately, we cant see everything that goes on everywhere all the time to verify it for ourselves. Given that hume explicitly tells us what he means, this is more vexing than one might expect. Humes essay on the credibility of miracle reports has always been controversial, 1. Matt mccormicks lecture on david humes argument concerning believing miracle testimony. In this article i wish to investigate whether there could be strong historical evidence for the occurrence of miracles, and contrary to much writing which has derived from humes celebrated chapter of miracles, i shall argue that there could be. This explains humes argument against justified belief in miracles and shows how it follows from, and is intrinsically connected with, his more general metaphysics. An enquiry concerning human understanding david hume. Different kinds of philosophy most of the principles and reasonings contained in this volume were published in a work in three volumes called a treatise of human naturea work which the author had planned before he left college, and which he. These problems are especially acute when miracles are used to establish a new religion. Hume on miracles it is evident in david humes writing of an equity concerning human understanding that he does not believe that miracles take place. Greenleaf, simon, 1847, an examination of the testimony of the four evangelists, by the rules of evidence administered in courts of justice, 2nd ed.
Enquiry concerning human understanding early modern texts. David hume quotes on miracles when anyone tells me, that he saw a dead man restored to life, i immediately consider with myself, whether it be more probable, that this person should either deceive or be deceived, or that the fact, which he relates, should really have happened. Topcs include arguments for and against hume, plus modern thinkers such as cs lewis, john polkinghorne, anthony flew, richard swinburne and maurice wiles. This book was written as a way to refute david humes famous essay on miracles. Twenty questions about humes of miracles peter millican humes essay on the credibility of miracle reports has always been controversial,1 with much debate over how it should be interpreted, let alone assessed. Responding to david humes argument against zondervan.
Different kinds of philosophy most of the principles and reasonings contained in this volume were published in a work in three volumes called a treatise of human naturea work which the author had planned before he left college, and which he wrote and published not long after. The miracle issue is at the heart of the philosophy of hume, as a proof of his empiricism. A summary of section x in david humes an enquiry concerning human understanding. Hume surely intends some irony here, however, since he concludes by saying that anyone who embraces a belief in miracles based on faith is conscious of a continued miracle in his own person, which subverts all the principles of his understanding enquiries, p. Humes definition of a miracle as an event which violates or breaks the laws of nature4 has been highly influential in philosophy. This book was written as a way to refute david hume s famous essay on miracles. Humes notorious essay of miracles is as cheeky as it is problematic. And addison, perhaps, will be read with pleasure, when locke shall be entirely forgotten. Occasionally someone insists that somewhere, for some period of time, the laws of nature stopped working and something absolutely batshit insane happened, like the sun danced in the sky or a bro rose from the dead, and he expects you to take him at his word. Humes many commentators, however, both pro and con, have. In light of humes central role in the scottish enlightenment, and in the history of western philosophy, bryan magee judged him as a philosopher widely regarded as the greatest who. Alevel as and a2 religious studies revision looking at the philosophy of religion and the concept of miracles.
Pdf critique of hume on miracles paul gerard horrigan. Of course it is hard for such a man to believe in extraordinary claims without being there to. David hume was a scottish historian, philosopher, economist, diplomat and essayist known today especially for his radical philosophical empiricism and scepticism. However, he does not attack them directly, but uses indirect arguments. Bayes, hume, price, and miracles john earman my topic is the bayesian analysis ofmiracles. What is clear, however, is that hume held that rational beliefs in miracles based purely on testimony are at very least highly problematic. This explains hume s argument against justified belief in miracles and shows how it follows from, and is intrinsically connected with, his more general metaphysics. In book x of an enquiry concerning human understanding,of miracles. So, let us try to get some feel for what this strategy involves by actually trying it on humes hypothetical example. Pdf on jan 1, 2012, yann schmitt and others published hume on miracles find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate.
Responding to david humes argument against zondervan academic. What he is saying is that the evidence will always be insufficient to warrant belief. Adapted from garrett, cognition and commitment in humes philosophy, oxford university press 1997, chapter 7. I have chosen to illustrate two socalled miracles from the new american bible and to show how hume would view these miracles.
In the 19thcentury edition of hume s enquiry in sir john lubbock s series, one hundred books, sections x and xi were omitted, appearing in an appendix with the misleading. Garrett, don 2002, hume on testimony concerning miracles, in millican, peter ed. Humes essay captivated western minds since the enlightenment and seemed to offer an airtight case against the possibility or probability of miracles. In this article i wish to investigate whether there could be strong historical evidence for the occurrence of miracles, and contrary to much writing which has derived from humes celebrated chapter of. Hume s ultimate target is the new testament miracles, especially jesus resurrection. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Clarendon press, 1982, 19, hume seems to disagree with mckinnon, everitt, and their ilk. The sort of system of religion at issue is that of popular religions.
Garrett, don, 2002, hume on testimony concerning miracles, in peter millican ed. Humes abject failure,the argument against miracles university of. This book takes piece after piece of hume s arguments apart and shows he did not put a lid on miracles after all. Twenty questions about humes of miracles cambridge core. Humes argument concerning miracles is interpreted by making approximations to terms in bayess theorem.
David hume and miracles by wayne jackson david hume 17111776, a scottish philosopher, was an agnostic, i. Click download or read online button to get david hume s argument against miracles book now. I will go along, for the time being, with the initial plausibility of this humean strategy. It should give the reader a more complete understanding builds on of both the structure of hume s argument and of his crucial and questionable premises.
Of course it is hard for such a man to believe in extraordinary claims without being there to witness them. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Thus they are examples of the fourth point, that different religious traditions have incompatible stories about miracles. This ar ticle clar ifies semantic, epistemolo gical, and meta physical questions addressed in the controversy. Throughout the rest of the readings hume states a few events which many believe are miracles.
Enquiry concerning human understanding7 flourishes at present. In 1748, the scholar issued his famous volume, essays. Miracles were ever so clearly revealed in scripture, it would be directly contrary to the rules of sound reasoning to give our assent. Humes first premise assumes that there could not be miracles and his second premise is based on his distaste for the societies that report miracles. Tillotsons writings, an argument against the real presence24 which is as concise and elegant and strong as any argument can possibly be. But the glory of malebranche is confined to his own nation, and to his own age. A miracle, he says, is a violation of the laws of nature. The same can be said for prophecy as can be said for miracles.
To make the discussion con crete, i will set it in the context ofeighteenthcenturydebate on miracles, and i will focus on the response to david humes celebrated argument against miracles that thomas bayes would have made and did in part make, albeit. Oct 26, 20 hume is taking it for granted that his audience would dismiss these putative miracles, despite the strong evidence in their favor. David hume s argument against miracles download ebook. Hume on miracles it is evident in david hume s writing of an equity concerning human understanding that he does not believe that miracles take place.
That would be really convenient, but its just not possible. David humes argument against believing in miracles has attracted nearly continuous attention from philosophers and theologians since it was first published in 1748. An advantage of this sort of argument from miracles over more abstract arguments, like the design and cosmological arguments. Concept of miracles alevel religious studies revision. David hume 17111776, a scottish philosopher, was an agnostic, i. It should give the reader a more complete understanding builds on of both the structure of humes argument and of his crucial and questionable premises. Hume s essay captivated western minds since the enlightenment and seemed to offer an airtight case against the possibility or probability of miracles. What do we know about humans and their propensities to report. Far from the traditional critics of miracles, most often based on their physical impossibility and clear violation of the laws of nature as they are in spinozas works, hume, in section x of the treatise of human nature, operates a methodological turn by reducing the. My aim here is to summarise what i take to be the most plausible views on these issues, both interpretative and phi. David hume, an inquiry concerning human understanding 1748 577 24. This formulation is then used to analyse the impact of multiple testimony. A critique of david humes on miracles maranatha baptist.
He discredits many of these miracles through his critiques. Hume is a man of logic, who believes in experience over knowledge. Hume concludes that religion is based in faith, not in reason. For the possibility of miracles from miracles in philosophical quarterly 18 1968. He was a sceptic and is noted for his arguments against the cosmological and teleological. Jun 24, 20 humes first argument seeks to show the impossibility of miracles. Humes critique of miracles michael gleghorn examines humes influential critique of miracles and points out the major shortfalls in his argument. Hume is not saying that miracles are impossible and do not happen. David hume s argument against miracles download ebook pdf.
Jan 24, 2014 hume s famous discussion of miracles is actually still used in the philosophy of religion today. Toward the end of humes essay of miracles, he states his final conclusion that no human testimony can have such force as to prove a miracle, and make it a just foundation for any such system of religion. Hume s view, set forth in his essay of miracles, has been widely thought to be correct. Hume s argument concerning miracles is interpreted by making approximations to terms in bayess theorem. While hume continues to argue against the possibility of miracles, christian and theistic philosophers who believe in the historicity and possibility of miracles have also made effort to respond to some of the philosophical questions aimed at denying the possibility of miracles and the plausibility of religious beliefs in general. Humes argument on miracles kevin rogers investigator 3, 2010 july introduction david hume 17111776 was an important figure in the scottish enlightenment. I should be much tempted, though, to say that the view of hume as a protobayesian, 9 or an intuitive bayesian, 10 greatly illuminates the ba6 jordan howard sobel, on the evidence of testimony for miracles. David hume and the probability of miracles 171 but that is a line of criticism which i will not pursue here. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of an enquiry concerning human understanding and what it means. Taylor westmont college abstract philosophers continue to debate about david humes case against the rationality of belief in miracles. There is no rational ground for trusting in miracles, and he suggests that all the miracles found in the bible are more likely the fabrications of their authors than a true revelation of the facts. A book of quality, brevity, and, in many places, charm, hume, holism and miracles is a major contribution both to the philosophy of religion and to hume scholarship. David hume, an inquiry concerning human understanding 1748.
Against belief in any alleged miracle we have, by definition of the word miracle. Humes famous discussion of miracles is actually still used in the philosophy of religion today. This book takes piece after piece of humes arguments apart and shows he did not put a lid on miracles after all. Hume adds a fourth point against supporting religious belief by appeal to miracles, viz.
107 1408 180 1448 1490 763 676 620 1536 642 1053 1170 84 651 1258 865 345 706 869 426 1224 376 1407 1488 903 725 752 1563 1498 131 718 406 280 619 1206 56 378 175 1327 1308 271 1439 174 1075 258 110 150